Siding Installation and Replacement (2)

Should I Replace My Siding or Roof First?

We are your local roofing and siding contractor with over 20 years of experience.

Servicing Rockland County, NY, Westchester County, NY & Bergen County, NJ…Call today for a free estimate!

Do you have a home that needs some TLC? Is your siding starting to rot or crack? Are the shingles starting to come off your roof? 

We know it can be overwhelming but this article will help you prioritize your next project. 

Before deciding whether to replace your roof or siding first, it is important to assess the current condition of your home’s exterior.

siding or roof project

Here are some factors to consider:

Age and Condition

The age and condition of your roof and siding are important factors to consider. If your roof or siding is showing signs of significant wear and tear, addressing the issue should take priority.

A damaged roof with leaks or missing shingles poses an immediate threat to the home’s interior and should be promptly replaced.

Similarly, old or damaged siding can allow moisture to seep into your home, causing mold and rot.

Project Budget

While both are important, one may be more urgent than the other.

If your roof is leaking, for example, it may be more cost-effective to repair it. If it’s beyond repair, replacing it could help you avoid costly repairs in the future. 

Curb Appeal

Both your roof and siding play a crucial role in your home’s curb appeal.

If you are planning to sell your home in the near future, you may want to consider which replacement will have the greatest impact on your home’s overall appearance.

A new roof can give your home a fresh, modern look, while new siding can completely transform its style.

Northeast Climate

We live in an area of four seasons. The harsh, cold winters and heavy rainfall can cause your roof to be more susceptible to damage. 

Similarly, the high winds and extreme temps can affect your siding. It protects your home from the outside elements and reduces your energy bill. 

Cost Comparison

Roof ReplacementThe cost of replacing your siding or roof can vary depending on several factors, including the size of your home, the type of material used, and the complexity of the installation.

In general, replacing your roof is more expensive than replacing your siding.

However, if you are considering both, starting with siding before tackling the roof can be a more cost-effective option.

This allows for easier access and installation of the siding materials, avoiding damage to the newly installed roof during the siding installation.

Case to Replace Your Roof

When considering whether to replace your siding or roof first, there are several factors to keep in mind.

One of the main arguments for replacing your roof first is that it provides protection for your home’s interior.

A damaged roof with leaks or missing shingles poses an immediate threat to your home’s interior and should be promptly replaced.

Another reason to replace your roof first is that it can be more cost-effective in the long run.

If you replace your siding first and then put on a new roof, it could damage the siding. This would result in additional repair costs for your home.

By replacing your roof first, you can ensure that your home is protected from the elements and that you won’t have to pay for additional repairs down the line.

Additionally, a new roof can improve your home’s energy efficiency. A roof that is old and damaged can allow air to escape, leading to higher energy bills.

By installing a new roof, you can improve your home’s insulation and reduce your energy costs.

Case to Replace Your Siding

If you notice any of the following signs, it may be time to replace your siding:

  • Cracks and rotting: If your siding is cracked or rotting, it’s time to replace it. Cracks can allow moisture to get in and cause damage to your home’s structure. Rotting can also cause structural damage and is a sign that your siding is no longer protecting your home.

  • Mold and mildew: If you see mold or mildew on your siding, it’s time to replace it. Mold and mildew can cause health problems and can also spread to other parts of your home.

  • Faded or peeling paint: If your siding is faded or the paint is peeling, it’s time to replace it. This is a sign that your siding is no longer protecting your home from the elements.

  • Increased energy bills: If you’ve noticed an increase in your energy bills, it may be due to your siding. Old or damaged siding can allow air to escape, making it harder to heat or cool your home.

Replacing your siding can also give your home a fresh new look. With so many siding options available, you can choose a style and color that complements your home’s architecture and enhances its curb appeal.

Additionally, new siding can increase the value of your home, making it a smart investment for the future.

Get a Professional Evaluation

One of the best ways to decide on your next project is to have a professional look at both scenarios.

A professional contractor like Segelman Shaw Roofing, Siding & Gutters can evaluate the condition of your roof and siding and provide you with expert advice on which project should be tackled first.

By getting a professional evaluation, you can ensure that your home improvement projects are prioritized in the most effective way possible!

For a free project evaluation and estimate, call our office at (845) 364-8200 or email

At Segelman Shaw, our continued success rests in the continued satisfaction of our clients

OUR Work


Tel : 845-364-8200 | 914-874-1197 | 201-530-9500


Roofing Contractor New City

Get Help Now!

New York: 845-364-8200

New Jersey: 201-530-9500

Westchester: 914-874-1197

LIC# ROC: H-09509-23 
LIC# WC:23380-H10 
LIC # Yonkers: 5443
LIC# NJ: 13vh01677400


Segelman Shaw Roofing Siding & Gutters

1 Executive Blvd., Suite 105B, Suffern, NY 10901

NJ: 201-530-9500
NY: 845-364-8200
WC: 914-874-1197 

Subscribe to our mailing list

Copyright © 2019 letsroof. All rights reserved.